#ls2 (irc2p) | #ls2 proposal review channel

zzz orignal, you said you were thinking about sending tunnel reject code 50 if you were not accepting any tunnels...

zzz have you made a decision yet? because I was going to rip out some of my code that handled that

orignal up to you

orignal you tell me what codes are allowed

orignal I use only 30 now

zzz anything is allowed, the spec is 0/10/20/30/50, I want to know if you have any plans to use 50

dr|z3d if G == go away, code 50?

zzz btw dr|z3d how you doing on postman's wrong LS problem?

zzz because it's not as harmless as I once thought since he's multihomed

dr|z3d haven't seen it here. not convinced it's my problem. maybe orignal's problem.

dr|z3d keep looking at my irc.postman LS, every time it tells me EdDSA.

zzz it's not an i2pd problem, because I see it here

zzz as stated

dr|z3d about time dual LeaseSets were put out to pasture, in any event.

zzz of course it may not be your problem, but until you prove it isn't, it's not going to be fixed

dr|z3d remind me again, what exactly are you seeing there?

zzz I'm looking at my LS tab right now and I have both

zzz both LS in netdb

dr|z3d so you have 2 separate LS for irc.postman?

zzz yes

zzz he's sending the wrong one, so we have to fetch the right one from ff

dr|z3d and that's persistent, transient, once in a blue moon? I don't understand why I can't see it here.

zzz you on that server?

zzz persistent, starting 10 minutes after connect

zzz how are you attempting to reproduce?

dr|z3d you see, that could just as much indicate that you both are broken and I've fixed the woopsie here :)

dr|z3d I'm always on postman's irc.

dr|z3d as stated, I'm regularly reviewing the leasesets I have for irc.postman in my netdb.

zzz do you have both dests in your address book?

dr|z3d if I do, it's not obvious.

zzz does susidns list both on the details page

dr|z3d I vaguely recall something being on the details page, which is where I looked, and from there I don't see anything about a migrated dest or whatever it would say.

dr|z3d so no, it doesn't list both.

zzz then you'll have to ^F for the DSA b32, not the hostname, on the LS page to find the other one

dr|z3d not found if I perform a host/b32 search, however, if I look on the LS page, I see 2 LS's tagged as irc.postman.i2p

zzz then the DSA dest is in your addressbook, and you do have both

dr|z3d so, sidenote, if I can see them both tagged as irc.postman, then I should be able to find them with the advanced search.

zzz don't do advanced search because that will fetch it

zzz I don't know why you said you've never seen them both in your netdb, but now you say you have both

dr|z3d I already did, maybe that's why I only had 1 before and now I have 2?

zzz ofc if you fetch the LS manually you're going to have it

zzz you cannot reproduce the issue via advanced search

zzz you don't try to test if he's sending you the wrong one by fetcing it manually

zzz verify you have both dests in susidns or not. Two sets of QR codes or one

dr|z3d have both in book, forgot that they were stacked.

zzz ok

zzz now

zzz as I said

zzz reproduce by connecting to postman, or staying connected, wait 10 minutes, dont be doing any manual lookups

zzz then ^F for postman on the LS page

zzz count 1 or 2, if 1, which one

zzz we've gotten nowhere on this in two weeks

dr|z3d I don't know what you mean by we.

dr|z3d "play with netcat" was about the extent of your help.

dr|z3d and the quality of the help, or the tone with which it's being delivered, hasn't much improved.

dr|z3d so, you know, if you want to keep on barking at me, carry on. but it won't achieve the desired result.

dr|z3d I hope I'm being heard. because these one way conversations are beyond tedious. you want a conversation on your terms when you decide you want it, and otherwise you want to shut any conversation down. that's not even remotely decent.

zzz heard

zzz the netcat advice still stands, if you don't want to set up an irc server, but that presumed you'd already seen the two dests on the LS tab

dr|z3d no need for extended testing. issue has been confirmed as resident in vanilla i2p, zzz.

dr|z3d check your current irc.postman leasesets, it's running on vanilla. I see both EdDSA and DSA here.

dr|z3d as discussed with postman, I suspected this issue predates the transition to I2P+. his router is currently <postman> an old 1.6.1-0

zzz hmm he told me irc was on plus

dr|z3d I'm telling you for the last 15m it's been on vanilla.

zzz but to make up for not being decent, I'll get right on it :)

zzz okey dokey

zzz thanks

zzz hmm what do I have to log to track this down...

zzz OCMOSJ... I2CP... streaming...

dr|z3d over a year ago I had transient issues connecting to postman's server, would just report some java error. this relates to that I suspect.

zzz I don't think it's OCMOSJ's fault... working backwardds...

zzz I think it might be ratchet?

zzz yeah it's a ratchet ack

zzz so it's sending both LS

zzz so I'm back to not a big issue

zzz this might get messy...

orignal same shit after restart. 2 leasesets

zzz yeah I'm working on it

orignal hhcy7zznltay2tzwdvtd37g2inptemz3hk5zmxyi57d3sxgxbseq 3 4

orignal mpvr7qmek2yz2ekegp5rur573z7e77vp3xqt2lfbco5i6nkfppcq 3 4

orignal this is answer to dr|z3d

zzz but it's sending both directly to you, you're not having to look it up

orignal he saked me to restart and try

zzz ok

orignal no, it seems I receive mpv

orignal and request hhc

zzz ok. in my tests so far I'm sending both

orignal e.g. I don't receive update hhc

orignal I request it from floodfiils

orignal maybe

orignal becuase I see diconnects too often

orignal it's sign and I don't receive update LS on time

orignal maybe I receive both but not every time

zzz yeah because it's multihomed, if it weren't sending it to you it would fail a lot more

orignal probably

orignal so you know what causes it?

zzz it's the ratchet-layer ack timer

zzz gets confused about which dest

zzz time to read our specs, I don't remember much about ratchet

orignal I told you this

orignal why do we even need to send dest

zzz what

orignal destination field in garlic

orignal you said because you might have multiple addresses on the same tunnels

zzz right, well I still need it :)

zzz but I'm forgetting for acks

orignal I set it just for compatubuntu with you

zzz I get an ACK REQUEST block, set a timer, then send it to the wrong place

zzz I didn't find the problem two weeks ago because I was looking at I2CP and streaming, not ratchet

orignal I'm wodering how I send new LS in this case

orignal probably I don't

zzz ok that took half a day, but I have a maybe-fix, untested, will test tomorrow