#i2p-dev (irc2p) | 2.8.2-6

zzz are you the bittorrent guy from reddit?

theoddone I am yes.

zzz ok good, glad you made it over here

zzz lets back up a bit

zzz you're writing a i2p bittorrent client with an embedded router, right?

theoddone well I'm trying :)

theoddone I'm not embedding the router just yet, still working through using an already running router

zzz what router do you plan to embed, and what language is your client in

theoddone I've not fully decided yet, client is typescript

theoddone Working on a tauri app, so the rust router is maybe likely.

zzz and right now you're using SAM, correct?

theoddone well I was using SAM for the torrenting, but I've writing a basic i2cp client so that I can utilize the dht

zzz what router are you using now?

theoddone i2pd and the java router both

theoddone I started w/ i2pd as it distributes binaries that I could distribute w/ the tauri app, but easier to debug w/ the java router as I can add logs and recompile/restart

zzz so you're kindof at a crossroads right now

theoddone after I get dht working I'll probably take a look at emissary

theoddone how's that?

zzz you need datagrams and streaming on the same session

zzz option 1) SAM v3.3, not supported by i2pd or emissary, you're locked into java router

theoddone well I'll probably switch over to i2cp entirely, just taking it a step at a time

zzz option 2) I2CP, you need to write both a I2CP client lib AND a streaming lib.

zzz there are exactly zero streaming libs out there

theoddone 🤔

theoddone streaming can be done over i2cp right?

zzz client lib pretty straightforward, I know eyedeekay pointed you to his old go lib, and you have the java lib to peek at

zzz yes ofc

zzz socket -- streaming -- i2cp -- router

theoddone I was using this previously for sam - npmjs.com/package/@diva.exchange/i2p-sam

theoddone ^ but pretty sure I could only dial to others, they couldn't dial to me.

zzz in java it goes socket -- sam -- streaming -- i2cp -- router

zzz in i2pd it's socket -- sam -- streaming -- router (no i2cp in the middle)

zzz we were talking to the rust router guy about possibly pulling out his streaming impl as a lib

zzz but he doesn't have any i2cp client-side code

zzz anyway, that's your crossroads, sorry for the bad news

theoddone ah no worries, will cross that bridge when I get to it

zzz nobody's done really anything with SAM 3.3 before, other than some lib support

zzz libtorrent doesn't sound too enthusiastic about it

theoddone Can't use sam 3.3 w/ dht any way right?

zzz wrong. that's the whole point of 3.3, to enable udp + tcp on the same session

zzz but nobody's actually done it, up to now

theoddone Looking at the docs here:

theoddone geti2p.net/en/docs/applications/bittorrent

theoddone ^ it mentions i2cp specifically

zzz sure.

zzz if you have any rust skills, you might want to collaborate with the rust router guy, perhaps there's a solution there somewhere

theoddone I don't ;_; just stumbling through

zzz so a simple i2cp client for datagrams isn't that hard, but what you didn't realize is you lost streaming when you switched from sam to i2cp

orignal zzz, I know why NSR decryption failed

orignal I haven't implemented resend properly

zzz it failed for me because of similar issues on my side, not because of your issues

zzz I exploded before I tried to decrypt it...

orignal wrong size basically

orignal and we need to save encrypted enpasulated key for follow on MixHash

orignal because we apply this MixHash after tag

zzz yup, it's a little tricky

zzz theoddone, I recommend you abandon I2CP for now, go back to SAM, work on 3.3 support, enable DHT if router supports 3.3, start testing with emissary, and when you get 3.3 working with java, start lobbying emissary to support it, and embed emissary

zzz I think that'll be the most promising path

orignal how is DHT related to sam 3.3?

orignal in mean time fixed NSR

theoddone orignal how is DHT related to sam 3.3? <-- I think it's more 3.2, which added support for I2CP messages which is how snark's dht implementation works.

theoddone Is the maintainer of emissary on IRC?

theoddone Also... I'm a little confused about SAM 3.2+ and I2PC, in order to support 3.2+ the router itself would need to translate from SAM <-> I2CP right? Maybe that's what you were saying before.

orignal no

orignal i2pd's SAM doesn't use I2CP at all

orignal also be aware that SAM 3.3 is complete mess

orignal uless you need something very special use SAM 3.1 that works everywhere

zzz thanks for the MR reviews eyedeekay, you're now four down and three to go

zzz everybody check out the new world map on the netdb page

orignal zzz, how do you decide no more NSR messages at Alice side?

orignal for PQ we need to cleanup

orignal e.g. I have to keep it for decaps, but it's at least 800 bytes

zzz orignal, I'll get back to you in a couple days, been busy, and have to fix my broken stuff first

orignal I'm not asking about broken stuff

orignal anyway no rush

zzz I know

zzz just saying I have to do that first

orignal because for PQ it's too much overhead

zzz but in general you drop your handshake state stuff once you get a data phase packet

zzz should be the same cleanup you do for regular ratchet

orignal can it be delyaed NSR after first data packet?

orignal but I don't do cleanup on Alice side for regular ratchets

orignal because overhead is small

zzz I don't remember much about the retransmission stuff, that's why I have problems, when I fix them then I'll be able to answer your questions

orignal thanks

zzz altonen, you a fan of prometheus?

altonen not necessarily fan but i wrote a testnet tool whih together with prometheus & grafana allows me to get good view of the entire testnet

altonen iow, convenience

zzz wasn't familiar but have been playing with it

zzz just got a simple console plugin working to export the jvm stats; looks pretty straightforward to export all our stats

altonen i wish java and i2pd supported it as well, could get even more detailed testnet runs

zzz we have about 500 stats we can export

altonen i rember seeing some list somewhere but lost it

altonen and stats.i2p ofc

zzz on /stats and /graphs in the console

altonen ty

dr|z3d looks like prometheus hooks up with grafana nicely. have you tried grafana, zzz?

dr|z3d prometheus.io/docs/visualization/grafana

zzz not yet

altonen grafana is honesly pretty great, the only reason i'm using prometheus

snex i use zabbix, it does both the frontend and backend. though a lot of it is in php(gross)

zzz just playing with prometheus web viewer out of debian for now

zzz just happy to be making progress after fighting class loader issues for a while

dr|z3d when you're ready: grafana.com/docs/grafana/latest/setup-grafana/installation/debian

zzz the plugin's only going to be 500KB

zzz actually under 300KB

dr|z3d very good

mareki2p Hi, I was talking to altonen that I was developing my own I2P capable application that communicates over I2CP. It was quite labourious, also I did it in pure C (so it could be usable from any language). After I realized I needed to implement streaming (equivalent of TCP over IP) I abbandoned it - postponed it indefinetly. And currently I'm doing other, non-I2P related things. But I like I2P quite

mareki2p a lot, so I will eventually come back to it. The result might be easily usable I2P I2CP library that could be included into any other software. But right now it is still in phase of wild dreams.

orignal why don't you start with raw datragms?

zzz ** theoddone

zzz also, theoddone, you asked who the rust guy was, it's altonen

orignal openssl 3.5 released

orignal hence I will be able to include PQ to the next release for some platforms

zzz that's at your own risk, we haven't agreed to anything yet

zzz ok I got 369 stats exported

dr|z3d screenshot or it didn't happen, zzz :)

zzz lol it's got the socksoutproxy UI

zzz so grafana talks to prometheus server and prometheus server talks to all the clients, right?

zzz I need prometheus server in the middle?

zzz I think that's right. I tried to get grafana to talk to the clients directly and it wasn't happy

dr|z3d yeah, prometheus is the middleware afaik.

dr|z3d I thought you might be using the socks UI, let me know if there's anything missing.

zzz think I'll rip out most of it, no need for much status or config

dr|z3d maybe config of the graphana instance, ports? grafana might be running on another box.

dr|z3d status is mostly just "yes, it's working" or "no, it's broken", perhaps streaming any logging provided by prometheus.

zzz this is the prometheus client, it knows nothing about grafana

dr|z3d ok